Minimalism is bullshit. Here’s what I do instead.

Even Marie Kondo gave up. In 2023 she said her house is messy now. If the queen of less can’t live it, maybe the problem isn’t us.
In January 2023, Marie Kondo, the woman who made millions of us hold up a T-shirt and ask whether it sparked joy, admitted her house is messy. She’d “kind of given up” on keeping it tidy after her third child. The way she was spending her time was right for her, she said, at that stage of her life.
I laughed out loud. Not at her: with her. Because I’d been quietly suspecting for years that minimalism is bullshit.
Not all of it. Let’s be fair first. Minimalism is right that most of us own a lot of things we don’t care about. The drawer of mystery cables. The third cheese grater. The conference lanyards. Getting rid of that stuff genuinely feels good, and anyone who has cleared a garage knows it.
But somewhere along the way, a useful clear-out turned into a moral position. An empty room became a sign of a good person. Owning six things became a personality. And the look of it, the white walls, the single perfect chair, the one artful branch in a vase, turned out to be very expensive. Minimalism, it turns out, is easiest when you’re rich enough to buy things back.
What it never gave me was a home that looked like someone lived in it. Or a head that was allowed to hold more than one idea at a time.
So here’s what I do instead. I’ve started calling it curated maximalism. (I didn’t invent the phrase; interior designers use it for gloriously layered rooms. I’m stealing it for everything else.)
The idea is simple: keep a lot, on purpose.
Plenty isn’t the problem. Plenty you didn’t choose is the problem. A wall of records you love is not clutter. A pile of post you haven’t opened is. The difference isn’t the number of things. It’s whether anyone decided they should be there.
To decide, I use a little test. Every thing, idea or project has to have at least one of four things going for it:
– A story. It means something. My dad’s beautiful velvet-lined engineering compass set. The ticket from the first gig I went to. The notebook from the year everything changed.
– A use. I actually use it. Not “might one day”: do.
– A place. It has a home, and it looks good there. If it lives on the floor, it fails.
– A future. It’s part of something I’m going to do. The half-built thing, the song I’m perfecting on the guitar, the idea I’m going to come back to.
If it passes, it stays, and it gets displayed, not hidden. That’s the permanent collection.
If it’s on its way somewhere, it’s a rotating exhibit: out for now, back in the cupboard later.
If I can’t let it go but don’t need it now, it goes into storage. Parked, not rejected.
And if it has no story, no use, no place and no future? Out it goes, with thanks. Museums call that deaccessioning. It sounds a lot less guilty than “decluttering”.
Here’s the bit I like most: it isn’t just about stuff.
I have a lot of ideas. Far too many, according to every productivity book I’ve read, which all say the same thing: pick one, focus, cut the rest. I tried. It felt like amputating limbs.
Now I run my ideas the same way I run my shelves. They all get written down. The ones with a future are live. The ones I love but can’t do yet are parked, never thrown away. Every so often I walk round the collection and rehang it. Some ideas come back out of storage years later and turn out to be the best ones.
Work’s the same. A career doesn’t have to be one thing. Projects are the same: you can have twenty, as long as you know which three are on the wall this month. Even a calendar can be curated, like a festival programme instead of a to-do list.
Minimalism says: own less, do less, want less. It’s a philosophy of subtraction, and subtraction eventually runs out.
Curated maximalism says: have more, choose it, show it off, look after it, and let go of the rest without the guilt. It’s generous. It’s a bit messy around the edges. It looks like a person lives here.
I don’t want an empty room. I want a museum of my own life, with good lighting, a storeroom, and me as the curator, not the cleaner.
So go and look at your fullest shelf. Don’t ask whether something sparks joy. Ask whether that something has a story, a use, a place or a future.
Then put it back; return it deliberately.



